National Velvet

National Velvet A year old English girl wins a horse in a raffle trains it and rides it in the Grand National steeplechase William Morrow Company

  • Title: National Velvet
  • Author: Enid Bagnold Earle B. Winslow
  • ISBN: null
  • Page: 127
  • Format: Hardcover
  • A 14 year old English girl wins a horse in a raffle, trains it, and rides it in the Grand National steeplechase.William Morrow Company

    One thought on “National Velvet”

    1. How do you rate a book like this? It's marketed as a children's book, but when I read it as a pre-teen there's no way I got all the subtleties that the author works into her themes. It was written in 1935, so of course it's aged. While I was reading the book, I was very aware that I was being given a slice of life for a way that people don't live anymore. How many people even know what butchering is, much less what it would be like to live in front of a kill yard? There's nowhere I know that wou [...]

    2. Though I've treasured this since I was 12, I'd completely forgotten to include it here until "Flicka"'s lyrical narration on the Hallmark Channel sent me scrambling for book excerpts online (thru red, swollen eyes, of course - hey it's a horse flick!) which led to a lovely "Velvet" detour. And what a lovely book it is - yes, yes, the triumph of the human spirit and all that, which, by the way, can never be overdone in children's or YA or ANY literature for that matter - but Enid Bagnold laid it [...]

    3. From BBC Radio 4 - Afternoon Drama:Fourteen year old Velvet is mad about horses. She knows 'there are pleasures earlier than love. Earlier than love, nearer heaven' in the form of horses.When she wins a piebald horse in a raffle, she recognises he's something special. He can easily clear five-foot fences, and he'll do anything for her. Soon, she and butcher's assistant Mi have their sights set on the biggest race in England. But how can a girl in 1930s England get near Aintree?Peter Flannery res [...]

    4. Not long ago, I read Cold Comfort Farm by Stella Gibbons -- written in the 1930s and set in rural England, just like this novel. There was an illuminating introduction to that book, in which the editor explained how Gibbons was parodying a writing style and subject matter popular in that era. (If you've read any D.H. Lawrence you will have a feeling for what I'm referring to: the inarticulate but powerful Nature of women and that sort of thing.) I couldn't help think of that essay when I read th [...]

    5. I really liked this book. Sometimes, I just can't stand books written in "old" style writing, but I just adored National Velvet. The characters, the plot, the descriptions it was all just very well done.First off, Velvet is a fourteen year old girl who aspires to become the best rider in England and win the Grand National. The amazing thing is, she actually does it! Now who wouldn't love such a heroine? She's very sweet and innocent, but very determined and she loves her family, and of course Mi [...]

    6. 'National Velvet' is not what I thought it would be. In fact, it was one of the more disheartening books I've read in a while. My issue is with the style and content of the story -- because the overall plot is just dandy! (i.e girl trains horse to become a race champion? Awesome.)Let's start at the beginning, shall we? My problems with it started on page 1. And yet, I thought that it must get better. It's a children's classic, right? So it has to be good. Or not, depending on who you are.So, pag [...]

    7. National Velvet is a story that every horse mad girl would devour within an instant and it was hence a novel that i fell in love with as a child/ teenager for its horse & horse racing content. The only way that i can describe it is when reading this story it was like opening a window into your heart and glimpsing ones dreams & aspirations within. Emotive and captivating this book really does tug on the heartstrings and leave you breathless, whilst following a double story of the young gi [...]

    8. I encountered this novel in a Short Story collection. Its negative aspects impressed themselves so much on my mind that I felt that the book itself warranted another separate review.Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against the content of the book. The plot-line while fragmented had some saving graces. Velvet & Mi's touching relationship was great. There was also some joy to be extracted from the family's Kafkaesque demeanour. What made me dislike the book profusely was the prose. It was to [...]

    9. Rather oddly written -- it took me a few chapters to get used to the style (and, rather like Narrow Dog To Carcassonne, which I read earlier this year, I just had to make peace with always being vaguely confused about what was going on). I picked this up from the children's section of the library, but it doesn't really strike me as a children's book unless you've got a really sophisticated reader who is interested in early 20th-century British family life. It's definitely more about a girl and t [...]

    10. I watched this movie several times as a child, but never read the book. I am a horse fan and so I've watched most movies that have something to do with horses. Even though it was about a horse, I always felt there was something not quite right in the film. It just seemedrange. I couldn't really identify with the main character.I now understand why the movie was like that - because the book is strange too :) The story isn't very cohesive and lacks depth. The family in the story is just bizarre. I [...]

    11. I haven't read this book for a while, but when I was like Velvet, a young, horse-crazy dreamer, this book was a definite big hit. I totally understood how Velvet would "loose her lunch" at the sight of a beautiful horse, and this book supported my own horse love. I loved the movie, but never could figure out why they made the horse a big chestnut instead of what he was, a Piebald, which is how he got his name. I remember when reading this book that I fell into the story, I think I breathed it an [...]

    12. Loved the movie, but hated the book! First of all the way the characters talked gave me a headache, and the fact that the father was a butcher made for my sensitivity for animal welfare go into overdrive. The story is a complete mess that never seemed to make me want to know what would happen next because I was so bored I just didn't care. Not only does Velvet get The Pie, she's also left four other horses from a man who commits suicide which for a children's novel I thought was completely inapp [...]

    13. I remember, as a kid, trying and trying to read this book. It was tough to get into. That wall of British culture that my American sensibilities could only barely breach. I desperately wanted to spend time with fictional horses. Can't recall if I finished National Velvet, or if I liked it, but I'll always enjoy way the title feels in my mouth.

    14. Exhilarating read about impossible dreams' being realized. I read this aloud to a ten year old daughter whose mild interest in horses had been quenched by a broken arm in the practice ring, but we both still loved the story. No, it's not realistic, but when did fiction always have to be?

    15. You know, when I was young(er) I loved this book because it was a good story. Now that I'm old(er) I'm stunned by just what a truly fantastic writer Enid Bagnold is.

    16. “I don’t like people,” said Velvet. “…I only like horses.”I'm so disappointed in myself that I didn't love this book, because I ADORE horse books. And this one has such an amazing premise: young, small town girl trains a nobody horse to be a champion. It's The Black Stallion. It's Justin Morgan Had a Horse. It's Seabiscuit: An American Legend. But this was more about Velvet than about The Pie.It's not that I don't love books about strong female leads. But there was so much story here [...]

    17. Like many girls in the last century, I went through a "horsey" phase. (Do girls still do that? I suspect not, but since my acquaintance with modern girls is small, I don't know.) I read all the horsey books I could find in our small local library. Billy and Bangs, Misty of Chincoteague, Brighty of Grand Canyon, Man O' War, etc. (I also read dog books, but I still read those.)I remember reading National Velvet either in late middle school or early high school. It was one of the books in the books [...]

    18. I saw the movie first, with Elizabeth Taylor and Mickey Rooney, and it was enchanting.This book reveals such depth and astonishing elements that I return to it more than the movie. This is no mere horse-crazy teenager. From the opening setting of the scene that introduces us to Velvet, to the rare involved comprehension of her entire family, each with their own remarkable quirks, including Mi Taylor, who is at first more of a general errands-man for the slaughterhouse business, I found myself qu [...]

    19. I read this long ago, as a horse-crazy girl. I am still a horse-crazy girl in a 55-year-old body, however, with horses! This book brought the world of steeplechasing, England's culture, racing culture, to me. Long before Dick Frances wrote about racing, Enid Bagnold wrote about a girl who dreamed of riding in the Grand National, the toughest Steeplechase in the world. Of course, girls couldn't be jockeys, so the heroine must pretend to be one. I lived vicariously through the heroine, who Elizabe [...]

    20. A bit slow in places. But written accurately as to what it all wouldve been like. So believable in that way. Encourages young people todream big and to kep moving towards their dreams. To say absolutely anything is possible. The characters are written without much depth in my opinion but are written with individual, charming and good natured personalities. Im not sure if people really are like that, but being it is more a story for teens Whos complaining. One thing. This book/ the movie are virt [...]

    21. One of the best books ever written about childhood, adulthood and all the days in between. Horse lovers will of course find this fascinating, but it's a book that's much more than a "horse-book". It's a book about family and relationships and knowing your own self and others. I can't recommend it too highly.

    22. The story was enjoyable, though not what I expected. Though it is indeed a horse story, it's also the story of a family in post-war England. I would imagine that it would be a bit of a slog for young people to get through; there's a lot of British slang and horse terms that many would find quite literally foreign. Avid horse lovers, though, will undoubtedly want to read it.

    23. I am extremely biased when it comes to horse books. This is no exception. I loved it as a kid and I read it again with my children. If you love horses or know someone who does, they will enjoy this book. However, I don’t think it holds up when compared to Black Beauty or The Black Stallion. Also, the movie is better (gasp!)

    24. I loved this book! Whether you're a fan of horse stories or not, this vividly detailed classic has everything from loveable characters to an exciting plot. Definitely one of my favorites, I highly recommend it.

    25. A young girl at church today told me she had five horses. This immediately brought National Velvet to mind, and I wanted to ask if she had read this most excellent book, but the service began and I did not get to. I dislike the movie with Elizabeth Taylor very much, mainly because MGM didn't take the trouble to find a piebald jumper, or even a white jumper that black patches could be applied to with dye, but instead added to the story to explain why Velvet called him "The Pie". Two of her sister [...]

    26. I read this not as a children's book, nor as a horse book, but because I haved liked some other of Bagnold's novels and I recall reading somewhere (one of the Nicolas, maybe) that this is a surreal, dream-like book which was only considered a children's novel because the protagonist was so young. And indeed, that is what I find -- the writing is highly crafted, I think perhaps deliberately modernist, and while there is both a child (a young teen) and many horses, the book is much more about fami [...]

    27. It has been a very long time since I've read this book. I'd forgotten how much the movie (which I also love) differs. In fact, even the cover of my book seems to take more after the movie than the book, with a dark-haired child (not "pale" as described in the book) and a chestnut horse (not the black and white piebald of the book). On the plus side, the book is charming and quirky, written in an old style that feels sort of disjointed but seems to suit the eccentricities of the Brown family well [...]

    28. My children and I just read this book together. The storyline was refreshing and tender but the writing style was choppy. The author gave beautiful descriptions, yet it was a hard book to read aloud. There were times that we could not decipher whose emotions we were reading about, a dog, horse, child or adult. We read many books outloud, this one was the most laborious. We kept going because we loved the storyline. After completing the book, we watched the movie starring Elizabeth Taylor. I know [...]

    29. I can't believe I've never seen the movie, nor read the book! I loved horses when I was kid and even took riding lessons. All has been rectified now. Will finally view the movie tonight. I did enjoy the horse related parts, since I am familiar with the termsI did not care for any of the butchering parts, skimmed over those passages pretty quickly. And for some reason found myself annoyed with Velvet's siblings. I wonder what I would have thought of story had I read it as a youngster?

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *