Grant Comes East

Grant Comes East In their runaway bestseller Gettysburg Newt Gingrich and William Forstchen answered the Civil War s ultimate hypothetical question What if Lee s army had won the victory within its grasp at Gettysbur

  • Title: Grant Comes East
  • Author: Newt Gingrich William R. Forstchen
  • ISBN: 9780312987268
  • Page: 385
  • Format: Paperback
  • In their runaway bestseller Gettysburg, Newt Gingrich and William Forstchen answered the Civil War s ultimate hypothetical question What if Lee s army had won the victory within its grasp at Gettysburg in 1863 Now, through the same extraordinary research and brilliant character studies, we take the next step of a provocative journey The Army of Northern Virginia is poisIn their runaway bestseller Gettysburg, Newt Gingrich and William Forstchen answered the Civil War s ultimate hypothetical question What if Lee s army had won the victory within its grasp at Gettysburg in 1863 Now, through the same extraordinary research and brilliant character studies, we take the next step of a provocative journey The Army of Northern Virginia is poised to invade Washington, D.C A besieged Lincoln calls on a general with a drinking problem to save the Union And in the East, Ulysses Grant faces a storm of calamity and rivalry and a war on the verge of being lostIn this extraordinary book, the battlefront and home fronts come alive through the eyes of ordinary soldiers and such little known characters as General Herman Haupt, commander of the U.S railroads, and the politician turned soldier General Dan Sickles a political arch enemy of Grant s As the best of plans are undone, and every strategy countered by another, GRANT COMES EAST builds to a stunning portrait of the war that was and the war that might have been

    One thought on “Grant Comes East”

    1. What a pity I have come into this trilogy with the second volume but never mind for it stands alone as it covers the six-week period when General Robert E. Lee's troops marched on Washington D.C beginning just 13 days after he had suffered defeat at Gettysburg.President Abraham Lincoln, despite the Gettysburg defeat, is in the White House defiant that his pledge to preserve the Union would be upheld at all costs. He has his Generals around him and has appointed Ulysses S. Grant as commander of a [...]

    2. In all fairness I have to start this review with a spoiler alert. If you haven’t read the preceeding book by these authors (‘Gettysburg‘) then I strongly urge you to so, since ‘Grant Comes East‘ picks up more or less where ‘Gettysburg’ stops. Still here? OK – my first comment on this book is how well the authors have managed the departure from ‘our’ timeline and the skill with which they use the best rules of counterfactual history to drive the plot. In ‘Gettysburg’, Lee [...]

    3. This novel, the second in the “Gettysburg” trilogy by the author combination of Gingrich & Forstchen, is a great read! I would strongly recommend that you read the first novel in the series before diving into this book. It can be read on it’s own but you will benefit greatly by reading this series in order. This series being a speculative alternate history of the events that happened in the summer of 1863 during the American Civil War will make much more sense if read with the first no [...]

    4. As with "Gettysburg", Gingrich and Forstchen have produced a compelling work of historical fiction that brings these battles to life for the reader. It captures the personalities of the political and military leaders behind this bloodiest of American wars, and paints them with greater nuance and context, as well as opening to the reader the fact that the catalysts for the war were not so black and white as we like to think now.This is especially important to understand today. As I write this, th [...]

    5. Just not as good as the Revolutionary War series. Too many descriptions of war battles. They are all the same so it gets monotonous. Aim, Fire lots of casualties and deathevery single time.

    6. Very good story. Continuing from where the last novel left off is the calling upon Lt.Gen. Ulysses S. Grant to save the day. From here on in Newt Gingrich expands on what might have happened if the Confederacy had won what was originally the Union victory at Gettysburg.The Confederate victory at Union Mills grants the Army of Northern Virginia the confidence to attack Washington, D.C. The battle for Washington was very good but the author paints a realistic picture in that the defenses of the ca [...]

    7. This was a typical book for the middle book of the trilogy. It developed the strategies of the protagonists as the story continued to develop, all heading for the final battle between the two adversaries. Much like "the Empire Strikes Back" in the original Star Wars trilogy. In this installment Grant has taken over command for the Armies of the Union. He has come to Pennsylvania from Mississippi to build a second army in the East, to be called the Army of the Susquehanna. Meanwhile, General Dan [...]

    8. This is the second book in this alternative history series for the Civil War. In the first book, Lee used different tactics at Gettysburg, and was able to get a major win. In this book, at attack on Washington D.C. fails, forcing Lee to change plans. His army manages to take Baltimore, and then has to fight a Union army under Sickles.This is an incredibly good book, showing the horror of war, sparing nothing in describing the injuries happening both to humans and to animals. It also takes a good [...]

    9. 1. This book has the narrowest bottom margin of any book I have read. On some pages it is even less than a single line. The good thing is the ink is of high enough quality to not have to worry about the lack of a clean place to place your thumbs.2. I was a little worried at first about reading alternative historic fiction, but that didn't turn out to be a problem. Quite a bit of what I know about history comes from well written historical fiction, so I can imagine myself thinking of some of thes [...]

    10. Part 2 of the trilogy. A lot more politics and discussions in this story compared to the first. Far less action, although there are some important battles.The Army of the Potomac is decimated at the end of the first book. Lincoln brings Grant in from the western front, to take total control of the army and reorganize after the decisive defeats in Pennsylvania. But, Grant has enemies in Washington and in the Union Army. Meanwhile Lee, after his devastating victory, is pressed by Jefferson Davis t [...]

    11. A Continuation of Gettysburg, this novel delves into the politics and intrigue on both sides of the war. Grant has enemies, Lee has pressures, and this seemingly outweighs the events on the fields of battle. I think it was competently written, but even more so than the first, this book drops into the stereotypes of valorous soldiers and altruistic generals. The horrors of war are but asides to the glamour of the cause - written by those who have experienced neither. It's a fan-boy piece about th [...]

    12. Again, a great "what if" book that can totally confuse you about the real outcome of the Civil War.tually causes me to read further about the actual Civil WarThis one basically has Washington isolated and hunkered down, about to be under siege by Lee and the Confederate army. Grant has come with his "Western" Union forces from Mississippi to take over the Union Army and the all but destroyed Army of the PotomacThe "result" is in the last book of this series, " Never Call Retreat: Lee and Grant- [...]

    13. In book one of this excellent alternative-history series, the battle of Gettysburg never happened; Lee retreated under cover of night and set up a trap that decimated the Army of the Potomac. Lincoln has brought Grant from the western theater and put him in charge of the new Union Army. Historical figures remain true to who they were in real history, but there are different battles & different results from actual history.

    14. A major reason I appreciated this book is because it features Ulysses S. Grant, someone I've always been fascinated with. Even without that, this book is an excellent sequel to "Gettysburg". It has less action, but the drama of the campaign makes for good reading. It also brings more of a political element than the first book in the series and openly discusses the fact that slavery was the cause of the war (something that is often ignored in books like these).

    15. This series was interesting. I thought the first book was the best, although I will give them all three stars since I can't do halves. The first book follows a widely held belief that the South could have won a battle in Southern Pennsylvania if they had chosen different ground. I do not agree with their conclusion that the War would actually have ended sooner with a Confederate victory in Southern Pennsylvania.

    16. Maybe it is because I hold Grant is such high esteem - He was clearly one of the greatest American Generals - but I could not put it down. I am not much for fiction and would never have bought this. Since it were given me, after it sat around two years I broke down and got started. It was a pleasant surprise. Newt is brilliant. The scenario was entirely believable, and in complete keeping with his character.

    17. If you are a Civil War history buff this a "must". This book is part of a trilogy of Civil War fiction that will very realistically take you on to the battle fields and into the personalities and minds of the important people of the period. The locations of where the battles take place is also fictional so this does , in my opinion, take something away from the book. The trilogy takes a "what if" look at what if the South had won at Gettysberg.

    18. Even if you are not interested in Civil War stories this series of three books will give you a clear sense of what it was like to live in that time period. It's our history, our ancestor's daily trials, losses; the agonizing decisions that would not only affect families but the future of our nation. Great read.

    19. Not as likable as the first book in the series, mainly because the action is too slow. The authors do a good job explaining why it takes so long for things to get going, but it does not make for interesting reading. However, I do appreciate be very careful characterization of General Grant, who is taciturn at likable at the same time.

    20. Second book of the trilogy. Gingerich and Forstchen continue their insightful application of the characters to the fictional shift in direction of the American Civil War. Although the plausibility of some of the action begins to stretch a bit, it is still an easy and fun read. After reading this, you should feel compelled to read the third and final book, "Never Call Retreat."

    21. Great sequel true to the spirit of the Civil War.The alternative history which is the subject of this trilogy is entirely believable and written very well, containing obvious expertise on all facets of the war! Highly recommend whole trilogy to all Civil War buffs.

    22. Exceptional telling of a great time in our country's history. I have read one book in this series before and was very impressed. This book did a great job of continuing that impression. This story was told in such a great manner and is such a easy read. Highly recommend.

    23. Pretty good! As with all alternate history you have to question whether or not the characters would have made the decisions that the author assumes; but a very entertaining read from a very tumultuous point in our history.

    24. I've always enjoyed historical fiction, however I am not a history buff. Hence, I find it difficult to recall which pieces are the "alternate" view of history. Nonetheless, these are well written, rich stories.

    25. The second book in the series. We meet Grant, and we follow Grant as he tries to figure out Lee. Grant has all the advantages of the industrial North, and he exhibits all his historic ruthlessness, even to those closest to him. A really good book.

    26. This was a very good book. I do like alternate history books. This was well done and along with the prior book provides a sound alternative to what happened during the Civil War.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *